67 E High Street & 5 N Walnut St
- Strong In-Place Yield with Tangible Upside: Priced at a 6.92% T12 cap rate with Year 1 stabilized cap projected at 8.83% on a 10-unit occupied basis. Year 5 yield-on-cost reaches 10.3% under conservative assumptions.
- Substantial Capital Already Deployed: Both buildings received new roofs within the last three years. Seven of eight units at 5 N. Walnut have been renovated, along with Unit C at 67 E. High. New windows have been installed across multiple units. A new hot water tank, basement sump pump, and full Unit B remodel were completed in 2025 (~$16,800). Unit F at Walnut is currently undergoing an $8,400 remodel scheduled for completion in April 2026.
- Attractive Rent Mark-to-Market Story: In-place average rent is $748 against a pro forma of $814 — a defensible 10.8% lift achievable through natural rollover. Unit F at 5 N. Walnut is scheduled to lease at $745 (vs. prior $610), and three additional Walnut units are turning within 60 days, providing immediate execution visibility for a new owner.
- Stable Anchor Tenant at 67 E. High. Unit A is leased to a local attorney who uses the space as a satellite office and recently renewed at $1,275/month through April 2027 — a long-tenured, low-touch tenant providing consistent base income.
- Owner Lease-Back Available on Vacant Unit: Seller is willing to lease back the vacant 2BR/1BA Unit B at 67 E. High at $900/month for six months at closing, allowing the buyer to stabilize cash flow while turning and re-leasing the unit on their own timeline.
- Strong Debt Coverage: At a 75% LTV with 6.15% financing, the deal supports a 1.91x DSCR in Year 1 and an average 1.85x DSCR over the five-year hold — providing substantial cushion for both lender and investor.
- Defensible Submarket: London sits 25 miles from Columbus along the I-70 corridor, within the gravitational pull of the Honda-LG, Intel, and Rickenbacker industrial expansions. Madison County offers tertiary-market pricing with secondary-market employment exposure.
- Limited New Supply: No meaningful new workforce-housing construction in the sub-$1,000 rent band is in the London pipeline, protecting in-place rents and providing pricing power on rollovers.
Property Description
Walnut Street Apartments is an 11-unit multifamily portfolio comprising two buildings on a single parcel in downtown London, Ohio — 5 N. Walnut Street (8 units) and 67 E. High Street (3 units). The asset is being offered at $675,000, or $61,364 per door, representing a 6.92% in-going cap rate on T12 income with a clear path to a 9%+ yield-on-cost within 24 months through rent normalization, RUBS implementation, and the lease-up of one remaining vacant unit.
Key Property Information
| Listing Status: | Unavailable |
|---|---|
| Listing Type: | Call for offers |
| Property Types: | Apartment Buildings |
| Price: | $650,000 |
| No. of Units: | 11 |
| Year Built: | 1930 |
| Opportunity Zone: | No |
| Price per unit: | $59,091 |
| Property Website | Click Here |
Investment Analyzer
Sponsored by:
Step 1Financing Calculation
Step 2Gross Rent Analysis
Please enter annual amounts.
Step 3Cap Rate Calculation
Step 4Final Deal Analysis
Similar Properties in the Area
835 Driftwood Drive
St. Cloud, Minnesota
Brokers
View All-
Remax Professionals
Re/Max Real Estate Professionals | New York
-
Jared Ennis
Central CA Commercial | California
-
Rick Recckio
Recckio Real Estate & Development
-
Eamonn McConnell
Avison Young - CA - ON - Greater Toronto
Lenders
View AllManagement
View All-
Essex Property Trust, Inc.
California
-
Josh A
California
-
Bob Tuteur
-
Andrew Schildcrout