515 Evening Inn Road

Property feature image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Address: 515 Evening Inn Rd, Oneonta, NY 13820, USA
New York & Tri-State + 2-4 Units
Created date: July 29, 2026
Date last updated: September 17, 2026
Price: $1,970,000Investment Analyzer NEW!

Property Description

An extraordinary opportunity to own more than 160 acres of scenic countryside with endless possibilities for income, investment, recreation, or multi-generational living. This unique offering features two single-family homes (one of which (#507) was newly remodeled in 2024) and a completely updated and renovated multi-family residence (#515) with a spacious 4-bedroom apartment, a 2-bedroom apartment PLUS dedicated space framed up ready to add two additional units for a greater rental income. Beyond the residences, the property includes four barns, garage spaces for 10+ cars, RV, boat, ATV's, snowmobiles & more. The outbuildings can provide additional rental income or space for your own equipment, workshops, livestock, or business ventures. The expansive mix of open fields, wooded acreage, and picturesque ponds create the perfect setting for farming, horses, cattle, sheep, hunting, hiking, ATV trails, or outdoor recreation. Whether you're envisioning a family compound, a working farm, hunting retreat, event venue, or a thriving income-producing investment, this remarkable property offers exceptional flexibility with significant future development potential. Located on Milford's Evening Inn Road, just minutes from downtown Oneonta and in the Oneonta School District, this is a rare chance to own a truly one-of-a-kind country estate where the opportunities are as vast as the landscape itself. Call today to schedule your showing and please plan for a minimum of 24-hour notice for the current tenants.

Key Property Information

Listing Status: Available
Listing Type: Call for offers
Property Types: 2-4 Units
Price: $1,970,000
No. of Units: 4
Year Built: 1900
Lot Size: 4,660.00 Sq ft
Opportunity Zone: No
Price per unit: $492,500
Property Website Click Here
Number of Bedrooms: 11
Number of Bathrooms: 6
Address: 515 Evening Inn Road, Oneonta, NY 13820, USA
Provided by:

Investment Analyzer

Step 1Financing Calculation

$
$
%
$
%
$
$

Step 2Gross Rent Analysis

Please enter annual amounts.

$
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
$

Step 3Final Deal Analysis

$
$
%
%
$
$

Similar Properties in the Area

1238 Manor Avenue

Bronx, New York
New York & Tri-State + 2-4 Units
Units: 2
Price: $890,000

34 Houston Avenue

Middletown, New York
New York & Tri-State + 2-4 Units
Units: 2
Price: $315,000

15 City Terrace

Newburgh, New York
New York & Tri-State + 2-4 Units
Units: 2
Price: $475,000

Brokers

View All

Lenders

View All