1538 W 11th Street

Property feature image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Property gallery image
Address: 1538 W 11th St., Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA
New York & Tri-State + 2-4 Units
Created date: October 9, 2026
Date last updated: October 11, 2026
Price: $2,200,000Investment Analyzer NEW!

Property Description

On the market for the first time in 52 years! Welcome to this legal three-family property in the heart of the desirable Bensonhurst neighborhood, cherished by one family for more than half a century and now ready for its next chapter. The home is spacious, light-filled, and full of character, with high ceilings throughout, a finished basement, and a garage. It is in excellent condition and move-in ready. The first floor unit is a 3-bedroom, 1-bath unit, and upstairs there are two units with 2-bedrooms, 1-bath each. Delivered fully vacant at closing, this triplex offers rare flexibility: live in one unit and let the other two work for you, or step in as an investor and set all three to market from day one. Situated on a quiet residential block in prime 11204, you're moments from schools, shopping, and dining, with easy access to the subway, local bus lines, and the Belt Parkway for a smooth commute throughout Brooklyn and beyond.

Key Property Information

Listing Status: Available
Listing Type: Call for offers
Property Types: 2-4 Units
Price: $2,200,000
No. of Units: 3
Year Built: 1935
Opportunity Zone: No
Price per unit: $733,333
Property Website Click Here
Number of Bedrooms: 7
Number of Bathrooms: 4
Address: 1538 W 11th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA
Provided by:

Investment Analyzer

Step 1Financing Calculation

$
$
%
$
%
$
$

Step 2Gross Rent Analysis

Please enter annual amounts.

$
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
%
$
$

Step 3Final Deal Analysis

$
$
%
%
$
$

Similar Properties in the Area

353-355 3rd St

Belle Vernon, Pennsylvania
New York & Tri-State + 2-4 Units
Units: 2
Price: $99,724

105 S Chapel Hill Road

Highland, New York
New York & Tri-State + 2-4 Units
Units: 2
Price: $549,000

3834 CAMBRIDGE Street

PHILADELPHIA, Pennsylvania
New York & Tri-State + 2-4 Units
Units: 2
Price: $189,900

Brokers

View All

Lenders

View All